Luxury Fire Island Homes - Fire Island Sales and Fire Island Rentals

category: Real estate agency, Commercial agent, Condominium rental agency, Mortgage broker, Mortgage lender, Property management company, Real estate agent, Real estate attorney, Real estate developer, Vacation home rental agency
address: 786 Evergreen Walk, Ocean Beach, NY 11770, United States
Phone: +1 631-570-8942
Monday9 AM–8 PM
Tuesday9 AM–8 PM
Wednesday9 AM–8 PM
Thursday9 AM–8 PM
Friday9 AM–8 PM
Saturday9 AM–8 PM
Sunday9 AM–8 PM

rayting: 5
services: From the business: Identifies as women-owned,
Service options: Online appointments, On-site services,
Amenities: Gender-neutral toilets,
Crowd: LGBTQ+ friendly, Transgender safe space,

Name: F******* C****
Date: 2024-02-07 15:45:19
Rating: 5
Comment: Our experience with Brian was nothing short of excellent. From him answering all our questions, showing us several homes and letting us take our time, to helping us with the closing of our dream summer home. Brian made the process smooth and his knowledge of Fire Island is extremely valuable.

Name: M*** Y*********
Date: 2024-01-15 18:49:21
Rating: 5
Comment: Great Service! Very helpful and considerate.

Name: M****** C*******
Date: 2024-01-09 01:21:06
Rating: 5
Comment: I can’t say enough about Tara and the job she did finding us a house. She was so patient with us. I would not hesitate to recommend her to anyone. She has a deep knowledge of Ocean Beach, she is super friendly with everyone and very connected to the community and we couldn’t have been happier with the job she did for us.
Click here to view more comments

Name: L*** W*****
Date: 2024-01-08 13:06:37
Rating: 5
Comment: Doug worked extensively to help me select a wonderful summer rental on Fire Island. His friendly, knowledgeable professionalism of the region and homes there made finding a rental an effortless task. Doug will absolutely be my go-to-guy for all my future Fire Island interests.

Name: C******** P******
Date: 2024-01-07 16:14:59
Rating: 5
Comment: Professional and a pleasure doing business with. Would highly recommend to anyone looking to rent , sell or buy.

Name: J**** C*******
Date: 2024-01-06 11:09:54
Rating: 5
Comment: Ive been working with Brian at Luxury Fire Island Homes for years. Brian makes the renting process dare I say - a pleasure. He is an expert, experienced, very communicative and most important - honest. Whenever I give Brian my criteria, he comes back with exactly what I asked for or if not - a solution. Brian is someone who earns trust and you never have to think twice about his recommendations. He understands what you want - and his approach is that this is what he wants. Couldnt say more good things.

Name: B****** B******
Date: 2024-01-04 15:56:39
Rating: 5
Comment: Sydney and Sue of Luxury Fire Island Homes exemplify attentiveness in their real estate expertise. Their dedication to understanding client desires and delivering tailored solutions is unmatched. With their attentive approach, they create personalized experiences, ensuring every aspect of luxury property transactions is handled with precision and care.

Name: M***** C******
Date: 2024-01-04 15:54:58
Rating: 5
Comment: Sydney and Sue from Luxury Fire Island Homes are the epitome of diligence in the real estate world. Their meticulous attention to detail and unwavering commitment ensures a seamless and top-tier experience for their clients. With their diligence, they navigate the complexities of luxury real estate effortlessly, delivering exceptional service every step of the way.

Name: L****** E*******
Date: 2023-10-11 21:13:08
Rating: 5
Comment: Susan McCoy and her team did an outstanding job of assisting us in the sale of our vacation home. They were there every step of the way from listing to closing. They have a great presence in Fire Island which made it so much easier to navigate through the closing process. Susan was an absolute pleasure to work with and I would highly recommend her! Bravo...Luxury Fire Island Homes for a job well done!

Name: M** R*****
Date: 2023-09-22 16:18:39
Rating: 5
Comment: Sydney was very professional & answered all my questions very promptly. Would highly recommend her!!

Name: M*** G****
Date: 2023-08-31 23:19:16
Rating: 5
Comment: From the start, Luxury Fire Island Homes demonstrated a commitment that went beyond the transactional. Their dedication to turning dreams into reality was palpable in every interaction. This wasnt just a real estate company; it was a team that understood the significance of finding a home that resonated on a personal level. Sydney and Sue, the dynamic duo behind this journey, brought a level of expertise that truly set them apart. Their savy insights into the Seaview market and their ability to grasp our preferences shaped a partnership that was rooted in understanding. Every recommendation they offered was a testament to their profound understanding of both the area and our desires.

Name: A***** P************
Date: 2023-08-31 23:18:07
Rating: 5
Comment: What set Sydney and Sue apart was their unwavering dedication to our satisfaction. They exhibited a remarkable blend of professionalism and approachability that made us feel not just like clients, but like partners in this significant life decision. Their transparent communication and genuine care made the entire process feel smooth and enriching. Throughout the negotiation phase, their impressive skills showed greatly. Sydney and Sue adeptly balanced our interests with the realities of the market, ensuring that the deal we secured was a true reflection of the propertys value. Their strategic guidance gave us confidence in our decisions and illuminated the path ahead. Beyond the transaction, the relationships Sydney and Sue cultivated were truly priceless. They took the time to understand our needs and concerns, creating an atmosphere of trust and camaraderie. This personal touch transformed our house-hunting journey into a memorable adventure. They helped me find my dream beach house in Ocean Bay Park and I truly do not think it could have happened without them!

Name: T***** M******
Date: 2023-08-26 03:48:37
Rating: 5
Comment: Sydney and Sue from Luxury Fire Island Homes are the true stars of the luxury real estate scene. Their unparalleled expertise in the Fire Island market is evident in every transaction they handle. These agents possess an uncanny ability to navigate the intricate landscape of upscale properties, making them an indispensable asset for anyone seeking top-tier service. Sydney and Sue redefine what it means to be savy real estate agents. Their deep understanding of Fire Islands luxury market, combined with their strategic approach to negotiations, consistently produces outstanding results. Partnering with them is like having a masterclass in property investment, where every move is thoughtfully calculated.

Name: O*** P*
Date: 2023-08-24 17:36:44
Rating: 5
Comment: From the beginning it was obvious that Luxury Fire Island Homes was more than just a real estate company; they were seasoned navigators of the intricate Fire Island landscape. Their commitment to understanding our likes and dislikes of our future home. Sydney and Sue, made this journey remarkable, and brought a level of savy insight that redefined our house-hunting experience. Their intimate knowledge of the area, coupled with their ability to truly listen, resulted in curated property options that perfectly aligned with our vision. Their dedication to showcasing the unique charm of each property was a testament to their profound appreciation for the Fire Island lifestyle.

Name: E*** T*****
Date: 2023-08-09 18:37:41
Rating: 5
Comment: I had the pleasure of working with Sydney and Sue from Luxury Fire Island Homes, and my experience was nothing short of outstanding. Their knowledge of the real estate market, coupled with their proactive approach, truly set them apart as exceptional agents. Sydney and Sue demonstrated an impressive depth of knowledge about the luxury property market on Fire Island. They were well-versed in the nuances of the area, including property values, market trends, and even the unique lifestyle offerings of each neighborhood. This wealth of knowledge helped me make informed decisions throughout my real estate journey.What truly impressed me was their unparalleled dedication to being productive and efficient. From the very beginning, Sydney and Sue exhibited a proactive mindset.

Name: T*** M*******
Date: 2023-08-08 21:39:51
Rating: 5
Comment: Sydney is incredibly knowledgeable about the fire island real estate market in the renting and selling space. She was able to provide me with valuable insights and advice every step of the way, and I always felt confident that I was making informed decisions. Beyond her expertise, Sydney was an absolute pleasure to work with. She was always friendly, responsive, and professional, and she made the entire process as seamless and stress-free as possible. She truly went above and beyond to ensure that I was satisfied with the outcome. I would highly recommend Sydney to anyone looking for a top-notch real estate agent. She is a true professional in every sense of the word, and I am so grateful for her help and guidance. Five stars!

Name: K**** M*******
Date: 2023-08-06 23:36:41
Rating: 5
Comment: I had the absolute pleasure of working with Sydney and Sue at Luxury Fire Island Homes to find and purchase my dream beach house. From start to finish, the experience was nothing short of exceptional. Throughout the process, they maintained open lines of communication, promptly answering all my questions and providing valuable insights. Their professionalism and attention to detail were evident in every aspect of the transaction. The closing process was a breeze, thanks to their proactive approach to handling all the necessary paperwork and coordination with other parties involved. Even after the purchase was complete, Sydney and Sue continued to provide support and assistance, going above and beyond to ensure I was settled comfortably into my new beach house.

Name: E*** S******
Date: 2023-08-06 17:38:00
Rating: 5
Comment: From the initial consultation to the closing of the sale, Sydney and her team were with me every step of the way. They provided valuable insights and advice on the local market, helped me set a realistic asking price, and created a comprehensive marketing plan that generated a lot of interest and ultimately resulted in a successful sale. Do yourself a favor and call Sydney.

Name: R***** M*******
Date: 2023-08-04 19:59:48
Rating: 5
Comment: My experience with Luxury Fire Island Homes was extremely positive, and I highly recommend them to anyone looking for a reliable and efficient property management service on Fire Island. Their professionalism, expertise, and commitment to customer satisfaction were second to none. If you are looking for a property management agent to take care of your property and your tenants, this is the company to choose.

Name: J**** G*******
Date: 2023-08-04 19:15:11
Rating: 5
Comment: Sydney and her team assisted us with our rental property for the summer. They were always available to answer any questions or concerns and consistently went above and beyond to ensure a smooth and stress-free process. If you want a summer rental, call Luxury Fire Island Homes.

Name: M*** S***
Date: 2023-08-04 15:38:00
Rating: 5
Comment: One of the standout qualities of Sydney and Sue is their extensive knowledge of the luxury real estate market on Fire Island. They took the time to understand our preferences and lifestyle needs, presenting us with properties that were a perfect match. Their good advice and insights were invaluable in making informed decisions, and their attention to detail during property showings allowed us to fully explore the potential of each home. Their professionalism was second to none. Sydney and Sue conducted themselves with grace and poise, navigating negotiations with finesse and ensuring we got the best deal possible. Their expertise in the luxury market allowed us to feel confident in the value of the properties we were considering, providing us with a sense of security throughout the process.

Name: J**** T*****
Date: 2023-08-04 15:11:51
Rating: 5
Comment: I cannot speak highly enough about our experience working with realtors Sydney and Sue in our search for a luxury Fire Island home. From the moment we began our journey, they made every step of the process stress-free and enjoyable. Their warm and approachable demeanor instantly put us at ease, and we knew we had found the right team to guide us through this significant investment was unmatched!!

Name: K*** M******
Date: 2023-08-04 13:57:10
Rating: 5
Comment: Sydney at Luxury Fire Island Homes is an outstanding vacation rental property agent who offers a luxurious and unforgettable experience. Fire Island has breathtaking views of the ocean and surrounding natural beauty for families to enjoy family time. It wouldnt have been possible without the assistance of Sydney and her team. They found the perfect place to provide us with a relaxing and rejuvenating getaway from the city. Call Luxury Fire Island for your next family getaway.

Name: D******* P*********
Date: 2023-08-04 01:59:29
Rating: 5
Comment: Luxury Fire Island Homes is a top-notch agency. If you are seeking a Fire Island rental home for your next getaway. The team is fantastic. The rental property that I ultimately selected exceeded my expectations in every way. It was clean, well-maintained, and had all the amenities I needed for a comfortable stay. I highly recommend Luxury Fire Island Homes as a vacation rental agent. The teams professionalism, expertise, and attention to detail made the process seamless and enjoyable. I would not hesitate to use their services again in the future.

Name: R***** S****
Date: 2023-08-04 01:57:06
Rating: 5
Comment: Sydney was my Fire Island vacation rental agent. From start to finish, the experience was exceptional. Sydney was incredibly knowledgeable about the area and the rental properties available. They listened carefully to my preferences and budget and provided me with a variety of options. Call Sydney for your Summer rental!

Name: M***** G*****
Date: 2023-08-03 19:48:34
Rating: 5
Comment: Sydney and Susan at Luxury Fire Island Homes is an exceptional real estate agency I recommend to anyone looking to rent, buy or sell a property on Fire Island. I was impressed with their professionalism, expertise, and commitment to customer satisfaction.

Name: J**** M****
Date: 2023-06-02 00:26:31
Rating: 5
Comment: If youre thinking of selling your home on Fire Island, you want to call Sydney from Luxury Fire Island Homes. Her team of experienced professionals is dedicated to helping you achieve your real estate goals, and they are committed to making the selling process as smooth and stress-free as possible. I called other agencies, and Sydney was the ONLY one who returned my call and sounded professional. She sold my property before it could even hit the market for a price that exceeded my expectations. Thank you Luxury Fire Island Homes.

Name: C**** M*****
Date: 2023-04-10 19:47:01
Rating: 5
Comment: John is very detailed, responsive, and knows the local market. As a first-time homebuyer, he was patient with answering our questions. He helped us win a property in a bidding war. I recommend him to anyone looking to purchase a home.

Name: J**** J****
Date: 2023-03-19 17:49:35
Rating: 5
Comment: Luxury Fire Island Homes is an exceptional real estate agency. I recommend them to anyone looking to rent, buy or sell a property on Fire Island. I was impressed with their professionalism, expertise, and commitment to customer satisfaction.

Name: J*** S******** A****** G*****
Date: 2023-02-04 15:24:28
Rating: 5
Comment: I hired Sydney and Susan to sell my home in Ocean Bay Park. Even though I did not want to put it on the market, they were able to bring me a really great buyer. I am walking away with more money than I thought I would. I also appreciated how responsive they were... all of my questions were answered immediately. Overall - I highly recommend Luxury Fire Island Homes. The only brokerage Ill ever use.

Name: P G R
Date: 2022-10-10 00:04:31
Rating: 5
Comment: I have been working with Fire Island Homes for my rental in Seaview each summer for the past 7 years. They are always very responsive and helpful in getting the rental arranged, finalizing the leasing contract and addressing any issues that might arise during the rental. I originally worked with Larry Litoff and then Brian Smith in the more recent years, and it has been a pleasure working with each of them.

Name: M*** M*******
Date: 2022-09-15 14:58:52
Rating: 5
Comment: Great environment, professional and nice people. They care about their clients and understood my needs. Quick to respond and very attentive, I really can’t say enough good things.

Name: D** F*****
Date: 2022-09-15 02:41:46
Rating: 5
Comment: Brian was a pleasure to work with- brought in excellent clean responsible guests. HighlyRecommend working with Luxury Fire Island Homes and Brian for all your rental needs!

Name: P******* M****
Date: 2022-08-16 12:39:03
Rating: 5
Comment: I have worked with Brian for many years as my rental agent. He is a true gentleman and it has always been a positive experience. He is a pleasure to work with.

Name: R***** L*****
Date: 2022-08-15 22:25:41
Rating: 5
Comment: We’ve been working with Brian for the past 3 years for our Fire Island rental house. He stays in touch with us throughout the year and is always available to answer any questions about our lease. It’s so nice having Brian waiting for us when we get off the ferry with a wagon to escort us to our rental. We can’t wait to rent again next year! Brian makes the process seamless!

Name: L**** F****** A***
Date: 2022-08-15 20:59:59
Rating: 5
Comment: Brian was excellent, he walked me thru the first time rental process. He gave us door to door help, showed us what we needed to know and was there to answer any questions. There were not many surprises along the way, the pictures did the property justice.

Name: R* P
Date: 2022-08-11 03:27:42
Rating: 5
Comment: Our family has loved Fire Island for years. It’s been several years since we rented a house but decided to this year. I looked on all the sites trying to find a house myself but was dealing with people I didn’t know and cancellation policies that allowed the owner to cancel at any time (after you made all your plans!). I finally called Brian Smith who I had used to help me find rentals years ago. Within hours I had several options and within days the deal was done. Brian has lived on the island for decades and knows everybody and everything. The week we spent in Ocean Beach was fabulous and the house was perfect. Thank you Brian!

Name: S***** D********
Date: 2022-08-02 15:56:58
Rating: 5
Comment: Great house in a great location. Spacious both inside and out. Pool was a hit. Service from team was top notch.

Name: V****** G****
Date: 2022-07-26 06:59:47
Rating: 5
Comment: Brian is great. I’ve enjoyed working with him through the years. He’s professional and conscientious, I completely trust him.

Name: M G********
Date: 2022-07-17 22:52:03
Rating: 5
Comment: This is our fourth year using Fire Island Homes! Very good experience.

Name: M*** S********
Date: 2022-05-21 20:09:34
Rating: 5
Comment: I am not a person who generally leaves testimonials, but when I have an experience that demonstrates such excellence and care, I am compelled to share it with the community I believe would benefit and have an interest.I live in St Louis, MO, but I have owned a home in Ocean Beach for 34 blissful years. Each year has been unique; sometimes our family using the house for the season, other years having seasonal, monthly, weekly renters.In the last 3-4 years the home was rented for the entire season by the same family. But this year that family decided to travel abroad instead of coming to Fire Island. That brought our house back on the market as a monthly rental property. I touched base with a few rental agents, all very nice and well intentioned, but it wasn’t until I received a call from Tara with Luxury Fire Island Homes that I experienced the highest level of professionalism, accountability and care.She was familiar with my home, (although I was never a client of hers) and she had a client that expressed a keen interest in renting my home for a month. In the course of our initial conversation I was so impressed with her kindness, and her thoughtful, thorough, methodical questions and practice of obtaining the essential information that would determine whether renting our home to her client would be equally beneficial for both parties which bodes well for a greater probability of a win/win situation for all parties.The other impressive piece is how her agency uses technology to provide a fast, efficient, seamless process of getting leases to the pertinent parties, ease in signing and returning the documents, and completing the financial transactions.I am so glad that I answered Tara’s call that day, and I look forward to a continued business relationship with her through the years.Thank you Tara!!

Name: c**** c********
Date: 2021-10-12 20:55:00
Rating: 5
Comment: As a home owner they only provided high quality tenants. They were also available anytime to help with anything.

Name: D***** K**
Date: 2021-10-10 21:42:41
Rating: 5
Comment: I’ve worked with a couple of their realtors for many years. They understand our needs and the families they work with have been great.

Name: C*** D****
Date: 2021-10-10 17:24:26
Rating: 5
Comment: Tara was wonderful and there to support us in the rental process. She found amazing tenants and communicated to us through the entire process. I highly recommend her for any rental needs. She made the process very smooth and was consistently helpful in advising us in the process. 10/10 would highly recommend her.

Name: l****** c*******
Date: 2021-10-08 14:22:05
Rating: 5
Comment: I have used this company for many years both for purchase of a home and for rental referrals for a rental vacation home. They are helpful and honest. They represent the best in their field and market place. I can highly recommend them.

Name: e***** l*****
Date: 2021-10-07 00:22:30
Rating: 5
Comment: Tara was wonderful to work with! She is kind, responsive and professional but most importantly, she knows Ocean Beach and how to connect your home to the perfect tenant. Thank you!

Name: J**** S*******
Date: 2021-10-06 22:42:14
Rating: 5
Comment: Brian @ Fire Island Homes has helped me rent my cottage on Fire Island for the past several seasons. I always find him to be extremely knowledgeable, professional, courteous and results-oriented. He has also gone above and beyond with an unexpected circumstance on those rare occasions.

Name: E*** L***
Date: 2021-10-06 14:55:12
Rating: 5
Comment: Look no further. Tara, Brian and this crew are terrific, and they will do everything possible to make it a great summer for you — whether you’re a renter or an owner. When Brian and Tara are handling my house to rent, I know it’s going to be a great experience. They have always presented exactly the type of potential renter I’m looking for — and in all the years I’ve listed my place with them I’ve never, not once, been disappointed. Look no further.

Name: A***** H********
Date: 2021-10-03 23:32:13
Rating: 5
Comment: Brian and the entire crew are amazing. They work tirelessly to provide the best possible level of professional service. More importantly,, they are all staples of the community.

Name: D**** D******
Date: 2021-10-03 21:12:16
Rating: 5
Comment: I’ve been working with FI Homes…renting my home and enjoying top notch professional service for many years. Many agents on the island seem to work part-time….but Brian Smith is full-time and full-service. As an added bonus he’s a pleasure to work with. I highly recommend working with this team.

Name: E******* M****
Date: 2021-10-01 22:58:52
Rating: 5
Comment: Having worked with many brokerage firms and real estate offices over the years, Luxury Fire Island Homes hands down takes victory for being the most community oriented and client centered real estate company! Their knowledge of Fire Island is extremely impressive. Working with Sydney and Susan is like working with a friendly neighbor. Highly recommend for all your selling, buying and renting needs!

Name: R** G****
Date: 2021-09-29 01:48:03
Rating: 5
Comment: Tara, is wonderful. great knowledge of fire island and super helpful.

Name: M****** R***
Date: 2021-09-27 02:20:53
Rating: 5
Comment: Tara Fishman is not only a gem of a human being, she’s a thoughtful, honest, patient and intuitive professional who has magically summoned the right places for my family, year after year. There’s no one who knows the charming particulars of fire island better. And no matter what you’re looking for - Tara will find it.

Name: N*** S* N****
Date: 2021-09-27 01:07:09
Rating: 5
Comment: Brian an his team at Fire island homes have always been reliable, dependable, an knowledgeable an goes the extra mile to make a deal possible, where as other realtors dont.Ive been dealing with Brain an Fire Island Homes for many years an theres none better. Nick .N.

Name: R*** T*****
Date: 2021-09-26 18:37:24
Rating: 5
Comment: Tara is responsive, resourceful, creative and fun. She knows the towns inside and out and is great to work with. Would never rent (or buy) with anyone else!

Name: C* R****** D***
Date: 2021-09-26 01:39:04
Rating: 5
Comment: I cant say enough about Tara Fishman. She is attentive, helpful and most importantly professional...but with a great sense of humor to boot. She knows Fire Island like the back of her hand and has insight like no other...thats what 50 years of experience will do for you. I will certainly be utilizing her services in the future.. Thank you Tara!!!

Name: J****** S*****
Date: 2021-09-25 18:36:18
Rating: 5
Comment: We always know we are in good hands with Tara. She calls back right away, knows the Island inside and out, and is very patient! I recommend her highly!!!!

Name: E******** M*******
Date: 2021-09-25 18:17:52
Rating: 5
Comment: Tara was so helpful and knowledgeable. She pointed us on the right direction and we found our dream home. A pleasure to work with.

Name: A** F******
Date: 2021-09-25 17:59:39
Rating: 5
Comment: Could not have been happier with the rental they found us and the service. They went above and beyond to make sure we were comfortable and settled.

Name: D******** C********
Date: 2021-09-25 17:53:24
Rating: 5
Comment: Tara at Fire Island Homes is excellent at what she does. Her personalized service makes you feel like you are her only client. Super trustworthy and knowledgeable. So lucky to have found her!

Name: M*** L***
Date: 2021-09-25 17:43:42
Rating: 5
Comment: Tara was thoughtful, knowledgeable, and a great advocate for us! Highly recommended!

Name: T***** N******
Date: 2021-09-23 00:54:16
Rating: 5
Comment: Brian is a consummate professional. We initiated our relationship with his representation in the purchase of our home and easily and quickly chose him to represent us in renting for the summer. His meticulous focus and attention to detail ensured all our renters to have an amazing experience while minimizing our exposure or involvement with any potential issues during the rental time. He went so far as bringing in a cleaning company to satisfy a unique request by the renter eliminating our need to get involved! Highly recommend Brian and his team and we look forward to a long relationship with him!

Name: m*** m*******
Date: 2021-09-22 22:37:54
Rating: 5
Comment: I have dealt with Brian Smith for two years and he has been great. He’s seems to go above and beyond with everything that he does. I highly recommend him.

Name: j** b*********
Date: 2021-09-22 22:34:29
Rating: 5
Comment: This business has rented out my home for me for the last 20 years. They always put responsible, respectable families in my homes and do an excellent job vetting who is renting my house. I would recommend them.

Name: T*** F**
Date: 2021-07-08 17:36:36
Rating: 5
Comment: Brian Smith replies very quickly with with homes we are looking to rent. Great contact!

Name: A**** G******
Date: 2021-04-14 19:26:05
Rating: 5
Comment: Brian is the absolute best!! He responded right away, had great variety in listings, and helped our group find the best homes not listed anywhere else. HIGHLY recommend!!

Name: S**** S****
Date: 2021-03-11 01:57:44
Rating: 5
Comment: Brian is responsive and attentive. He went the extra mile to make sure I found the house I needed for our group. Finding this house was no small feat considering I was late to the game with a very small budget. Thanks Brian!!

Name: s****** h***
Date: 2020-10-07 22:07:00
Rating: 5
Comment: Brian is the consummate professional, responsive at every turned and truly listened to our needs and feedback. It’s a pleasure working Brian and the team.

Name: D***** B***
Date: 2020-09-21 18:43:31
Rating: 5
Comment: I have been coming out to Fire Island for about 5 years and with each year stepping up my rental. First few years was share houses and this past summer was 6 weeks at a house. Brian has been extremely responsive and helpful during our search this past summer. Hes extremely professional as well; alas we found the house directly via the owner so didnt end up going with one of the houses that Brian had, but he still was willing to give us his time and perspective. I am looking to rent again for the summer of 21 and Brian has already been early and thorough with our search. I am confident that we will find a home to rent next year and that Brian will be the one who helps to get us there!

Name: c********
Date: 2020-07-28 15:07:41
Rating: 5
Comment: I called concerning a last-minute reservation, and I was happy to get Brian on the phone immediately. He assessed our situation quickly and said he would look into possible options for us. He sent an email with one option for us within 5 minutes and followed up with a call with several more. He is definitely plugged into the community and knows his stuff. I really appreciated his willingness to try and help out with an unconventional, last-minute request. I will definitely call on him in the future, and hopefully our plans will be more worked out then.

Name: L*** T***
Date: 2020-06-06 12:07:54
Rating: 5
Comment: The most knowledgable and best relationships with owners-trusted!

Name: P**** A R******
Date: 2020-06-06 00:03:17
Rating: 5
Comment: Very responsive. Provided exactly the type of properties we wanted. Thanks Brian

Name: n***** c
Date: 2020-05-17 20:31:00
Rating: 5
Comment: My family was looking for our 2020 summer vacation and we came across the website. I emailed Brian Smith and in no time at all he responded and provided us with beautiful rentals to choose from! The quick response and great choices have us really looking forward to our the first of I am sure many vacation rentals with Brian!

Name: R** S******
Date: 2019-11-08 21:52:17
Rating: 5
Comment: Brian is the best! He knows the right questions to ask to determine your priorities and delivers outstanding property options each year. He goes out of his way to accommodate his clients and is accessible throughout the entire rental process. I highly recommend Brian and look forward to my next rental experience!

Name: C******** C***
Date: 2018-05-16 16:18:53
Rating: 5
Comment: It has been 3rd year in a row renting from Fire Island Homes, LLC and we cannot say enough how great it is to work with them. It is our first year working with Brian Smith, and boy he really nailed the right properties by our specifications. He is timely with his responses and even answered my call while he was away in Florida! I enjoy working with him and I look forward to many many more future summers in FI.

Name: S**** P****
Date: 2018-04-03 14:34:07
Rating: 5
Comment: I have rented houses on FI from several different places over the years. Brian and Fire Island Homes, LLC is by far the best! I have been working with him for 3 years now. He has taken his time to show us the different properties (in the middle of winter no less) making sure we get the perfect house. He is pro active on what I need to look out for and pay. He is quick to reply and send over all paper work. Someone from his office is always in the area if we have any questions or need assistance. I have recommend him to several of my friends. A pleasure to work with!!

Name: B** S******
Date: 2018-04-02 15:08:51
Rating: 5
Comment: I have been using Fire Island Homes for years and they always help me find the perfect summer getaway. Its been a great experience and I look forward to working with Brian and the rest of the staff for years to come.

Name: k**** d***
Date: 2018-03-30 20:04:50
Rating: 5
Comment: I have been working with Brain for the last 6 years and he is on top of the summer rentals. Easy to reach, responsive. I would highly recommend using this company to rent from.

Name: J**** P******
Date: 2018-02-23 14:28:53
Rating: 5
Comment: I recently purchased a house in Ocean Beach, Fire Island. Brian Smith was my agent and he was a pleasure to work with and very professional. Even after the sale Brian continues to help with settling in. I highly recommend Fire Island Homes, LLC.

Name: J******* B****
Date: 2017-10-25 17:15:08
Rating: 5
Comment: I have been working with Fire island Homes for more than 10 years. I have always found them to be knowledgeable about the real estate offerings on Fire Island and have always been able to answer the questions I have about the real estate market. I find their web site to be easy to use and packed with useful information about what is going on in the communities. Their Facebook and Instagram pages also have timely pictures from the island just when I am starting to miss being there. You can’t go wrong with these guys, they do Fire Island real estate right.

Name: T***** R****
Date: 2017-10-25 16:55:03
Rating: 5
Comment: The Best in Ocean Beach NY. I have been an owner her for 15 years. Brian Smith has always gotten me the best renters. I had only problems with the two times I used other realtors. I highly recommend them.

Name: m**** l*****
Date: 2017-10-01 12:13:30
Rating: 5
Comment: I have rented quite a few homes through Brian Smith and Fire Island Homes. Each time Brian has emailed me a variety of choices, met with me to narrow down the search, and walked me through every step of the process. I was so impressed with his attention to detail that when I decided to search for a home of my own, my first call was to Brian. Brian offered insight, advice and helped me through every step of the process. Long after the process has been completed, I still rely on Brian for his advice and his knowledge about the Fire Island community. I would highly recommend Brian Smith and Fire Island Homes. Any vacation on Fire Island should start with a phone call to him!

Name: A***** L***
Date: 2017-10-01 00:04:16
Rating: 5
Comment: Ive rented through Brian at Fire Island Homes multiple times and have always had great experiences. I highly recommend Brian and Fire Island Homes.